SME builders' 2026/27 survey: planning and viability bite harder, nutrient neutrality fades

The Home Builders Federation's annual State of Play report, published on 5 November with Close Brothers Property Finance and VELUX, finds 63% of SME home builders have delayed or stopped work on a site in the past year. Planning delays and condition discharge are still the biggest barrier, but the picture on nutrients, grid and drainage connections has shifted.

Quick answer: The HBF’s State of Play 2026/27 report, published on 5 November 2026, surveyed 213 SME home builders between 2 June and 2 July 2026. 63% have delayed progressing a site or stopped work on site in the past 12 months, and 41% expect to bring forward fewer sites in the next year. Planning delays and discharging conditions remain the top major barrier at 88% (down from 94%), with cumulative viability pressures up sharply to 82% (from 64%). Nutrient and/or water neutrality has halved as a major barrier, from 33% to 16%. The report does not change any regulation: Part L, Part G and nutrient neutrality rules all apply as before.

The headline numbers

The survey is the sixth year HBF has run it, and planning delay has topped the list every time. This year’s major barriers to growth:

BarrierMajor barrier, 20262025
Planning delays and discharging conditions88%94%
Cumulative viability pressures82%64%
Local planning authority resources81%—
Taxation and regulatory burden72%—
Lack of government support for first-time buyers72%58%
Materials supply and cost60%41%
Statutory consultees52%63%
Nutrient and/or water neutrality16%33%

What builders say they have done about it over the last 12 months:

Looking ahead, 41% expect to bring forward fewer sites, 21% expect to exit certain markets, and 67% say the availability of viable small and medium sites has got worse.

Infrastructure and environmental barriers

Several lines in the report go beyond the planning system itself and land on the technical side of a scheme:

The fall in nutrient neutrality as a major barrier is the clearest change. The report does not explain it, so treat any reason as a guess. It is worth remembering that the survey closed in early July, before the first draft Environmental Delivery Plan for Norfolk was published. In catchments without an EDP in force, nothing has changed: you still need a calculated nutrient budget and secured mitigation before permission is granted. Even in Norfolk, the environmental watchdog has questioned whether the draft plan’s evidence is there yet.

The £76,000 figure

HBF repeats its estimate that taxes, regulation and higher build costs have added about £76,000 to the cost of a new home since 2020, over 20% of the average new-build value. Building regulations, the Future Homes Standard, nutrient neutrality, BNG, materials and labour are all named as contributors, but the report does not give a figure for each. The two lines it does quantify are materials inflation (over 40% since 2020, about £28,500 a home) and labour (up 23%, about £8,500 a home).

The report acknowledges the Budget pledge of no major building regulations changes for the rest of this Parliament, apart from safety, but says it will do little to address the wider cost burden. That pledge does not move the Part L 2026 dates. For non-higher-risk work, Approved Document L 2026 and the Future Homes Standard still apply from 24 March 2027, and plots with an earlier application only keep the old rules if work on each building starts before 24 March 2028.

What HBF is asking for

The report’s recommendations include a moratorium on new policy costs, taxes and levies, repeal of the Building Safety Levy, faster and more certain planning decisions for SME developers, and longer-term funding for local planning authorities. These are asks, not government policy.

What it means in practice

For SME developers the practical message is about the parts of the programme you control:

  1. Front-load the technical evidence. With condition discharge still the top complaint, and only about half of discharge applications decided on time, the energy, water, drainage and nutrient packs should be final before the discharge application goes in.
  2. Design for Part L 2026 now on sites that won’t start before the transitional deadline. Retrofitting a design after a missed deadline costs more than getting the fabric, services and PV right first time.
  3. Check nutrient and drainage constraints at land appraisal, not at planning. A barrier fewer builders rank as major is still a hard stop if the site sits in an affected catchment.

If you want us to look at the SAP, water, overheating or nutrient evidence on a scheme before it goes to the council, get in touch.

Sources: HBF: State of Play 2026/27 (November 2026) · Specification Online: Nearly two-thirds of SME home builders delay or stop work on sites as viability pressures mount (5 November 2026).

Got a project this affects?

Send us the drawings and the dates and we'll tell you which version applies, what it means for your specification, and what it costs to sort.